There Needs to Be New Teams in the Winter Classic

On January 1, 2008, the NHL held its inaugural marquee regular season event, the Winter Classic, at Ralph Wilson Stadium in Orchard Park, New York. The outdoor game between the Buffalo Sabres and Pittsburgh Penguins was an immediate success for the league. The next year, the event moved west to the Windy City where the Chicago Blackhawks faced off against the Detroit Red Wings in the highest rated televised hockey game in over three decades.

Since then, there have been four other Winter Classics with the only pause being in 2013 due to the lockout. In total, nine teams have participated in the six years it has been held with the Red Wings, Penguins, and Philadelphia Flyers each appearing twice.

This year’s game is set to be played in Washington D.C. at Nationals Park. Playing against each other will be the Blackhawks and Washington Capitals – two teams that have already made appearances in the event.

The event’s success

There is no doubt that the brainchild of NBC executive Jon Miller will be here to stay for a long time. The game has twice reached TV ratings of 2.9; most recently in 2014 when the Toronto Maple Leafs played the Red Wings at the Big House in Ann Arbor, Michigan. That game also had a record setting attendance of 105,491.

(Tom Turk/The Hockey Writers)
(Tom Turk/The Hockey Writers)

HBO even joined in on the fun when it produced three parts for its reality television series 24/7. The series followed the two teams in the weeks prior to the big outdoor game and gave fans a glimpse of what happens behind the scenes leading up to gameday. Even though HBO opted out of this year’s event, the popular series will live on with EPIX taking over.

The Winter Classic is a valuable source of revenue for the league and it has even spawned the NHL Stadium Series in an attempt to get more teams involved. However, the fact remains, the Winter Classic is the premier outdoor game.

The need for new teams to be involved

Recent news of the Boston Bruins being the front-runners to host the 2016 Winter Classic has many fans of other teams crying favoritism. It’s no secret that league commissioner Gary Bettman and NBC executives are trying to feature teams in large market areas but they are missing an opportunity to draw in new fans to the sport or add to an already large fanbase such as Minnesota’s. A game between the up-and-coming Minnesota Wild and perennial Cup-contenders St. Louis Blues in a hockey-crazed state like Minnesota would be tantamount to holding it in the northeast.

Jared Spurgeon (Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)
Jared Spurgeon (Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports)

If the league decides to not host the game in small market areas, then they should consider featuring teams with small fan bases that need an infusion of prime time spotlight. Teams like the New York Islanders, Tampa Bay Lightning, or even Ottawa Senators have plenty of talent on their roster for an exciting game.

So how about it, commissioner? If Boston does end up being the host city (again), will you at the very least let other teams join in on the fun?

8 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
JT Smith
JT Smith
10 years ago

It would be more interesting if the Winter Classic became the All Star Game. What would be better than watching the best players in the world play outdoors. It might actually make the game worth watching.

Andrew Bensch
10 years ago

I used to love the winter classic, id watch it every new years day, but with their being multiple outdoor games every year, personally the winter classic has lost it’s appeal. It’s not special anymore

mightymouse316
10 years ago

What bismith1? They have had games in Canada, there are fewer teams so they don’t get it as often…

Al
Al
10 years ago

Bowl games are on! Who watches hockey on New Years day?

mightymouse316
10 years ago
Reply to  Al

Real hockey fans? You have 78 (76?) bowl games that are boring and repetitive with plenty of commercials.

lup12
lup12
10 years ago

@bismith1. The “Winter Classic” in Canada is called the “Heritage Classic” and it usually involves Canadian teams. Last year I think Vancouver and Ottawa played each other. Calgary played recently too.

In fact, the first NHL outdoor game to ever be played was between Edmonton and Montreal a few years ago. It was a Canadian idea.

I guess the Heritage Classic doesn’t get much coverage in the U.S.

bismith1
10 years ago
Reply to  lup12

I’m well aware of the Heritage Classic, but you’re correct, U.S markets don’t pick it up. Having the Winter Classic in Canada I think would expand the market across country borders. And As for Al, I’ll be at several bowl games, hockey streams nicely on my iPhone.

bismith1
10 years ago

I think there needs to be some sort of event in Canada. I’d personally like to see an outdoor game played in Quebec City. That could serve as a tester game to see what kind of crowd was drawn. I have no problem with teams being featured that will draw crowds, but I feel that Canadian teams are being left out.