The truth is that a hockey writer could write about the Toronto Maple Leafs Mitch Marner almost every day. He’s that interesting a player and person. On the hockey side, Marner is a dynamic 200-foot winger playing for his hometown Maple Leafs. Like all hockey players, sometimes he succeeds, and sometimes he fails.
On the personal side, he’s defined by a fascinating blend of complexities and contrasts. On one hand, while he’s shown immense talent, he’s never hit the 100-point mark for one reason or another. Yet, off the ice, he seems to believe he should be paid as one of the NHL’s elites. Given the effective lure of his potential and the complex, frustrating work of his player agent, Darren Ferris, he was probably paid too much and too young. In many ways, in the face of that fact, he’s drawn the ire of critics who – although they tip their hats to his talent, can’t cover their eyes to what seems to be his puffed-up entitlement.
In Marner’s Quest for Respect, He’s Dragging Two Huge Anchors
His journey through the NHL is marked by moments of immense frustration for fans and critics alike. In his quest for respect and adoration from the Toronto fanbase, his sailboat is dragging two heavy anchors.
Related: Revisiting Maple Leafs & Marner’s 2019 Contract Negotiations
The first anchor is the immense pressure and expectations from fans and the media, magnified by the microscope of his contentious contract negotiations. If he made a few million less and the contracts were reached more amicably, the pressure would be less. The second anchor has been his sporadic underperformance during the postseason. While the fact is that he has done marginally better than his Core Four cohorts like John Tavares, Auston Matthews, and William Nylander, he’s been roasted far more with far less reason.
Despite these anchors, Marner’s extraordinary talent and infectious charisma keep him afloat in this tough hockey market. By all accounts, he’s loved by his teammates “in the room.” Still, with all his talent, he’s become exceedingly newsworthy as the team moves toward an offseason where many rumours are folding and unfolding. Are the Maple Leafs shopping him? Will he waive his no-movement clause? What are the six top landing places for Marner? Everyone seems to want to jump on the pile.
Marner Has Become the “Victim” of Paparazzi, Ambulance-Chasing Journalism
While one can argue that Marner has brought it upon himself, his trip from golden boy hometown hero (when he was on an entry-level contract) to pariah has been rapid. The result is that Marner has often found himself a prime target of modern-day tabloid journalism, much like the sensationalism associated with the notorious National Enquirer. He’s become a “victim” (it’s hard to call him that) or target of what I call paparazzi journalism.
Related: Today in Hockey History: June 12
Ambulance chasers have relentlessly scrutinized his life by creating exaggerated headlines that mirror the paparazzi’s invasive tactics. Such journalism prioritizes sensational content and eye-catching headlines over factual accuracy. The result? Marner has been portrayed in an even more controversial light. As a result, he has become fodder for tabloid-style stories that exaggerate his actions and motivations, making him appear more controversial than he is. Sadly, the impact of such scandalous and frequently questionable reporting contributes even further to a skewed public perception of this youngster.
As a Person and Player, Marner Is More Complex than He’s Portrayed
This offseason, he’s become a clickbait carrier pigeon. Yet, he’s far more complex than his public image suggests. The reporting paints this picture of a player whose career deserves these despicable perceptions.
On the other hand, Marner’s charisma and talent make him undeniably lovable. His playmaking abilities and on-ice vision are second to none. He’s a defensive wizard who can read and disrupt plays. He performs well on both special teams units. He brings value to the team, and the team is arguably better off with him. Still, he hasn’t yet helped carry his team to postseason success. In this market, that makes him guilty as charged.
(Photo by Kevin Sousa/NHLI via Getty Images)
While the idea of a Core Four has been panned for years, it is not the issue. The issue is the sizable contracts and how they cannibalize the salary-cap space. What team would not want four elite offensive talents? At the same time, what team can survive the salary-cap bite that chews up and spits out the quality of the remaining roster spots?
Related: Toronto Maple Leafs & Mitch Marner Are at a Crossroads
On the ice, Marner consistently delivers moments of magic. Off the ice, his commitment to charitable endeavors and engaging personality further endear him to the community. He has a unique ability to bring joy to the game and palpable enthusiasm.
The Yin and Yang of Marner’s Career Might Be Moving to Another Locale
This yin and yang of Marner’s career—balancing the frustrating and the despicable with the lovable and the admirable—highlights the intriguing complexities of a young athlete who continues to captivate. His every move (and moves he doesn’t make) challenges the perceptions of those who follow his every move. Yet, it’s come to the place where it might be better if Marner leaves town.
If he leaves, I will miss him. I wonder if and how, with the wisdom of hindsight, he might have proceeded differently.
