Pittsburghers Love Saad; Penguins Are Better Off Without Him

by

Pittsburgher Brandon Saad, formerly a restricted free agent for the Chicago Blackhawks, was traded to the Columbus Blue Jackets for a haul of players and a 4th round draft pick. The Blackhawks, fearing that they could no longer afford to retain him, got what they could.

The Pittsburgh Penguins were confirmed to have made an attempt to acquire Saad, but were unable to seal the deal.

Good.

He’s From Here

Pittsburghers love other Pittsburghers.

An outsider simply needs to understand that the City of Pittsburgh often views itself like one big family.  The family’s prized children are the athletes who play for city teams.  Besides winning championships, there is nothing a Pittsburgher loves more than rooting for another Pittsburgher.

The Steelers had the likes of Charlie Batch and “McKeesport” Mike Logan. The Pittsburgh Pirates have Neil Walker, who grew up in the northern suburbs of Pittsburgh, just like I did. Even after years in the majors, it’s still an often mentioned fact.

Saad is from the northern suburbs as well, so there was already grassroots interest in acquiring him before the first trade rumblings were heard.  Fans had it in their minds that Saad was a prized piece to the puzzle and that he was a Pittsburgher made it all the more real.  It felt like something that would be too perfect of a fit to pass up.

The Pens front office, feeling seemingly the same way, did not want to pass on an opportunity at Saad for a second time (They passed on Saad during the draft).  While the details of the offer made has not yet come to light, one can assume – based on the quality of players sent by the Blue Jackets to Chicago – that Derrick Pouliot or Olli Maatta were not a part of the proposed deal.

The Cost of Emotional Attachment

So, yes, Pittsburghers wanted a fellow Pittsburgher to come home and make good for the hometown team.  It’s natural and understandable.  Until you take a look at the numbers, anything is possible.  Well, signing Saad would limit a lot of options.

It’s been reported that Saad was asking Chicago for what amounts to an absurd amount of money.

Don’t get me wrong, I like Saad. I like his game and what he can bring to a team. I like that he’s 22 and on the rise. Yes, I like that “he’s from here.”  What I don’t like is that cap number. Woof!

That number is about twice as large as the current Chris Kunitz deal. While Kunitz is on the wrong side of 35, and may not be worth his contract – is Saad THAT good?  Is he twice the player that Kunitz is?

Saad at half his asking price, somewhere around Kunitz’s current contract numbers, is how I could categorize his value. At $6.5 million per year, that’s simply too much for a cap strapped team to handle.  The Blackhawks knew they couldn’t handle it, so they made the move.

Stages of Grief

Both media and Pens’ fans responded to news of the deal by progressing through the stages of grief:

Denial:

Anger:

https://twitter.com/OlliMaatta/status/615991789162356736

Bargaining:

https://twitter.com/Jay32600/status/615993220829462528

Depression:

Acceptance:

 

Cheer up everyone, it’s not the end of the world. The Pens dodged a cap bullet and still have major assets to move in potential deals to come. I, too, empathize with you as someone who would have liked to see Saad pull on his hometown team’s jersey, but the time isn’t right.

Still, it would have been sweet.